163 -Addressing Treatment Noncompliance and Resistance
Counselor Toolbox for Mental Health...

00:00 / 55:58

Addressing Treatment Noncompliance
Instructor: Dr. Dawn-Elise Snipes

CEUs for this presentation can be found at https://www.allceus.com/member/cart/index/search?q=noncompliance

~ Examine some of the reasons for treatment noncompliance including
~ Learning vs. Performance
~ Low motivation
~ Not feeling heard / White-Coat Syndrome
~ Roll with Resistance
~ Tipping the Scales
~ In what ways are your clients noncompliant?
~ What things are your clients often resistant about?
~ Is NOT a respect issue
~ Can result from
~ Lack of knowledge
~ Lack of ability
~ Lack of effective skills for that person
~ Lack of motivation
~ No buy-in to new skill or behavior
~ New skill or behavior less effective than old skill or behavior

Types of Resistance
~ Issue resistance
~ Related to a specific issue such as smoking cessation, changing a dietary pattern, physical activity, etc.
~ Relational resistance
~ Has to do with the relationship between you and the client.
~ There is discord in the interactions.
~ Comments may include
~ You don’t understand
~ You can’t help me

Learning vs. Performance
~ Client is motivated but not following through
~ Do they know it?
~ Can they do it?
~ Do they have confidence that they can do it?
~ How do you teach adult learners: ABCD
~ Acquisition: Auditory, Visual, Kinesthetic
~ Buy In (Why do I care?)
~ Connected to current/prior situations
~ Divided into manageable parts

Learning vs. Performance
~ How do you teach performance?
~ Role play
~ Hypothesizing
~ Systematic exposure/experience
~ Example: Distress Tolerance for Anxiety
~ Have client develop distress tolerance plan
~ Remember a time last week when you were distressed and explain how you could have applied the plan
~ Role play a situation that often causes you distress and use the new skills
~ Envision yourself successfully navigating a stressful situation using new skills
Learning vs. Performance
~ Systematic exposure/experience
~ Example: Distress Tolerance for Anxiety
~ IRL: Practice using the skill at least once a day on things that cause you anxiety.
~ Identify how successful it was
~ Identify what parts worked
~ Identify what you could do differently next time

Tipping The Scales of Motivation
~ Stages of Readiness for Change
~ Precontemplation
~ Contemplation
~ Preparation
~ Action
~ Pain  Withdrawal  Romanticize/minimize drawbacks to old behavior
~ Motivation
~ Stages are NOT linear
~ Why is the new behavior less motivating?
~ Benefits of old behavior (Drinking, Eating, Cutting, Screaming, Sleeping)
~ How can you meet those needs now
~ Drawbacks to new behavior (Less immediately effective, less enjoyable, hard to remember to use them)
~ How can you minimize those
~ Benefits of the new behavior
~ How can you maximize those
~ Drawbacks to the old behavior
~ How can you magnify/remember these
~ What about the new behavior is less motivating
~ No buy in
~ Too hard/complicated/theoretical
~ Assumes skills not available (i.e. need to pause before DT; Need self awareness before communicating needs)
~ Not individualized
~ Meditation/PTSD/ADHD
~ Writing and reading for Extroverts
~ Support group and social gatherings for Introverts, cultures that prefer privacy
~ Tried and failed


Motivation Maintenance
~ Regularly review and add to the
~ Benefits of change
~ Drawbacks to staying the same or returning to old behaviors
~ Frequently explore
~ New or lingering drawbacks to change (still not happy or convinced)
~ New or lingering needs resulting from giving up old behavior
Rolling with Resistance
~ Avoid a direct head-on argument and the “righting reflex”
~ Arguments often result from fear or anger.
~ Identify the threat
~ Express Empathy (defuses defensiveness)
~ Try asking/listening instead of telling/talking
~ Empower the client to come up with possible solutions or alternative behaviors themselves rather than forcing suggestions on them.
~ Develop discrepancy to highlight the difference between what they say they want and their current behaviors

Rolling with Resistance
~ Double sided reflection
~ Use knowledge client has already given which conflicts with current statement.
~ Client: I know you want me to only work 40 hours a week so I have more time with my family and I am less stressed, but I can’t do that!
~ Clinician: You can see that your work is creating some real problems in your marriage, but you’re not able think about reducing your work schedule.
~ Reframing
~ Identify a different perspective when a situation or other person is aggravating
~ Client: My husband is always telling me I worry too much. It really bugs me.
~ Clinician: It sounds like he really cares about you and is concerned, although he expresses it in a way that makes you angry. Maybe we can help him learn how to tell help you deal with your anxiety in a more helpful and supportive way
Rolling cont.
~ Reflect the resistant statement
~ You don’t like the idea of coming here/journaling/support groups
~ Reflect the tone of what you are hearing
~ You seem to feel hopeless
~ You are not happy that…
~ Reflect ambivalence
~ On one hand you want to start feeling better/fix your marriage, but on the other hand the time commitment seems overwhelming/you don’t see anything working
~ Acknowledge the resistance
~ We seem to be arguing
~ I hear you feel like [this] won’t work
~ Support choice/self-control
~ You are in charge
~ I am more concerned with what you are going to do than what you are not going to do
~ What do you think might help/work?

~ Noncompliance often results from fear/hopelessness/disempowerment
~ Continuing to press the issue is like getting a 3 year old to eat Brussel sprouts
~ Increasing motivation and rolling with resistance are ways of helping clients
~ Identify why they are noncompliant
~ Explore ways to deal with that (change the intervention or their attitude)


By continuing to use the site, you agree to the use of cookies. more information

The cookie settings on this website are set to "allow cookies" to give you the best browsing experience possible. If you continue to use this website without changing your cookie settings or you click "Accept" below then you are consenting to this.