201 -Overcoming Biases and Anxieties in Clinical Supervision
Counselor Toolbox

 
 
00:00 / 60:48
 
1X

Providing Feedback, Addressing Anxiety and Overcoming Biases
Instructor: Dr. Dawn-Elise Snipes, PhD
Executive Director: AllCEUs.com, Counselor Education and Training
Podcast Host: Counselor Toolbox & Happiness Isn’t Brain Surgery

Objectives
~ Review types of supervisory intervention
~ Identify types of biases and ways to overcome them
~ Identify types of anxieties and how to address them
Feedback and Intervention
~ Can be triaged into three levels:
~ Immediate intervention
~ Non-immediate intervention
~ Suggestions
~ Designed to enhance counselor competencies
~ Personal characteristics (self awareness, cultural competence)
~ Philosophical foundations
~ Communications (verbal and nonverbal)
~ Counseling skills
~ Adjunctive or administrative activity
~ Ethical behaviors

5 Types of Supervisory Intervention
~ Facilitative: Brings about discussion through nondirective questions
~ What might the next step be?
~ What other interventions might you have used?
~ What other explanations exist?
~ Confrontive: Addresses specific action or behavior and requires the counselor to answer a question about it
~ Why did you choose to pursue that avenue with the client?
~ What was your intent when you asked…
~ What is your timeline for preparing for the audit on January 25?

Cont…
~ Conceptual: Contributes new information and a different way of visualizing the case
~ Sally is a 27 year old female with a 7-month old child and presents with symptoms of depression
~ Depression?
~ Grief?
~ Hormone changes?
~ Stress and sleep deprivation?
~ Prescriptive: Directs the counselor to respond in a particular manner the next time a certain set of circumstances occurs
~ The next time the client begins blaming his wife for things…
~ The next time a client calls at the last minute to cancel…
Cont…
~ Catalytic: Moves the process along by asking provocative, or what if questions
~ What if the client were to gather baseline data for a week
~ What if you used the empty chair technique
~ What if the client were to try [x intervention] for 1 week
~ What if you held the client on point for X-topic
~ What if you helped the client reconceptualize the problem

~ In later practice this is often the feedback you get from colleagues when you ask for suggestions.
~ Good type of intervention for ethical issues
Feedback is
~ Supervisor's response to the data presented
~ Lack of data leads to ineffective feedback
~ Designed to:
~ Help the supervisor understand (get inside the head of) the supervisee
~ Bring about a positive change in the professional life of the counselor
~ Supportive, challenging and pragmatic
~ Not “It was a good session”
~ But “It was a good session. I liked how you… And …. I am wondering… If I had to give one suggestion or area to work on it would be….”

Effective Feedback
~ Is elicited rather than imposed
~ Supervisees should be seeking feedback
~ Is timely
~ Is communicated clearly, directly and with regard to specific issues
~ Is constructive and descriptive rather than critical or judgmental
~ When the client revealed his concern about his anger issues and you responded by saying, “well, once we get your anxiety under control, your anger will probably not be a problem” he seemed to shut down. I am wondering what you intended to communicate and what your rationale was
~ Not: “Your response to the client was totally inappropriate”
Cont…
~ Is directed toward changeable behavior
~ Stay on task
~ When clients… then you should …
~ Is not used as a disciplinary weapon
~ Constructive feedback is presented with positive feedback and/or recognition of work well done

Methods of Providing Feedback
~ Trunking or breaking down information into manageable bites
~ Make a list of all the things you want to go over. Cover one at a time
~ Rapport/Therapeutic alliance
~ Adherence/relevance to treatment plan
~ Interventions used
~ Ethical Issues
~ Providing nonthreatening but thought-provoking were challenging questions
~ Sharing one's own experiences in concrete terms
~ Providing support and encouragement
~ Suggesting alternatives
Effective Challenges are
~ Tentative
~ What would have happened if
~ I am curious why you chose
~ Help me understand what you were hearing when
~ Phrased with the tone of care and respect
~ Tied to reinforcement
~ Okay, I totally see your rationale. That was a great choice.
~ I know it felt like a lot went wrong in that session, but you seem to really have a grasp on what to do differently next time.

Effective Challenges are
~ Built upon steps which have already been successfully accomplished
~ You have learned the technique and practiced it in supervision, how do you feel about trying it with clients next week.
~ Focused on specific and concrete behaviors
~ Review your tapes for how many times you used an audible pause
Countertransference
~ Countertransference: Projecting unresolved personal issues onto a client or supervisee)
~ Signs
~ A feeling of loathing, anxiety, or dread at the prospect of seeing a specific client or supervisee
~ Unexplained anger or rage at a particular client
~ Distaste for a particular client
~ Mistakes in scheduling clients, missed appointments
~ Forgetting client’s name, history
~ Drowsiness during a session or sessions ending abruptly
~ Excessive socializing

Countertransference cont…
~ Examples of supervisee transference include:
~ The supervisee’s idealization of the supervisor.
~ Distorted reactions to the supervisor based on the supervisee’s reaction to the power dynamics
~ The supervisee’s need for acceptance by or approval from an authority figure.
~ The supervisee’s reaction to the supervisor’s establishing boundaries
Countertransference cont…
~ Supervisor countertransference include:
~ The need for approval as a knowledgeable and competent supervisor.
~ Unresolved personal conflicts of the supervisor activated by the supervisory relationship.
~ Reactions to individual supervisees, such as dislike or idealizing some supervisees (whether or not warranted) in comparison to other supervisees.
~ Sexual or romantic attraction to certain supervisees.
~ Cultural countertransference, such as catering to or withdrawing from individuals of a specific cultural background
Transference & Countertransference
~ Supervisors need to be aware that
~ Transference reactions that may arise even from the way you decorate your office
~ Not all emotional reactions to clients are countertransference
~ Not all countertransference reaction to harmful
~ Can give you information about reactions the supervisee might bring up in others
~ The difference between healthy personal or therapeutic responses to clients and unhealthy responses arise from the supervisor’s own unresolved conflicts.
~ Compassion for a therapist struggling with a client who has relapsed vs. anger at the therapist for not doing it “right”
Determining Skill Levels
~ Supervisors should not:
~ Assume a developmental level based on the counselor's experience and training (biases toward programs or prior placements)
~ Assess counselor simply on the basis of initial impressions
~ Determine developmental level simply on the basis of performance in one or two domains
~ Supervisors should use several sources of information to assess counselor's development including assessments by
~ Former supervisors
~ Measurements administered by the current supervisor
~ Counselor self-assessments
~ Client ratings
~ Work samples

Biases Affecting Supervision
~ Recency: Remembering only what happened last week, not six months ago
~ Overemphasis on one factor (rapport) as opposed to the bigger picture (counseling techniques, documentation, ethics…)
~ Unforgivingness leading to an inability to acknowledge improvement
~ Prejudice based upon negative attributions
~ Favoritism
~ Grouping or stereotyping
~ Indiscrimination, being either too approving or too critical
Protecting Against Biases
~ Use standardized rating scales for all employees/supervisees
~ Creating behaviorally anchored rating scales
Sources of Anxiety for Supervisees
~ Beginner's quandary or the fear of the unknown
~ Role plays
~ Co-facilitation bridge
~ Live (remote) observation
~ The spun glass theory that their clients are delicate objects
~ Have supervisees list all of the things the client has survived
~ Have supervisees put themselves in the client’s shoes
Sources of Anxiety for Supervisees
~ Performance and approval anxiety
~ Ensure early and frequent successes
~ Always remember to point out the positive
~ Remind supervisees that this is a learning process that takes YEARS
~ Validate their anxiety with self-disclosure… “The first time I…
~ Dominance anxiety (unwillingness to speak up)
~ Reinforce the notion that the supervisee knows the client better than you do
~ Point out how much more effective it is if the client asserts his/her rationale/needs/wants
~ Ensure the individual development plan is tailored around the supervisees stated goals

Dealing with Anxiety
~ Identify the supervisees anxious behaviors/defense mechanisms
~ Tardiness
~ Overuse of/dependence on the supervisor
~ Irritability
~ “Forgetting” to talk about a certain client or use an agreed upon intervention
~ Assist the supervisee and recognizing and exploring the cognitive pattern, and the needs it expresses
~ Need for control
~ Need for approval
~ Need for perfection
~ Lack of trust in the client
Cont…
~ Challenge the irrational beliefs with questions
~ Every client I have has relapsed
~ None of my clients like me
~ I am a bad therapist because he dropped out…
~ Assist the supervisee in constructing (and remembering to use) rational and logical thoughts related to the anxiety or anger
~ My client is so resistant. She blocks me at every turn…
~ My client has no respect for my time. He always cancels at the last minute
~ Ask the supervisee to write down the name of each client and state what aspect of each case worries him or her

Summary
~ Feedback can be anxiety provoking for supervisors and supervisees
~ Develop a metaphor
~ Remember the intent and spirit
~ Ensure you provide positive as well as constructive feedback
~ If supervisees are doing well, pose hypotheticals to ensure they are able to respond to a variety of situations
~ Types of anxiety include
~ Beginners quandary
~ Spun glass
~ Need for approval
~ Dominance

Summary
~ Biases include:
~ Transference
~ Prior experiences with students from that program
~ Cultural
~ Other individual factor
~ Recency
~ Unforgivingness
~ Overemphasis on one factor
~ Grouping or stereotyping
~ Indiscrimination

By continuing to use the site, you agree to the use of cookies. more information

The cookie settings on this website are set to "allow cookies" to give you the best browsing experience possible. If you continue to use this website without changing your cookie settings or you click "Accept" below then you are consenting to this.

Close